Consumer advocate says PPL customers would pay $157 million of a $178 million line for a data center. A ruling isn't due until July 2027
Shapiro has joined the case, the first governor in at least 15 years to intervene at the PUC. He also attacked PJM members' vote on new governance rules this week. The House's data center cost bill, HB 1834, never got a Senate vote.
The state's consumer advocate is asking the Public Utility Commission to change how PPL Electric Utilities charges data centers, arguing that the utility's rules leave its existing customers paying for grid upgrades the data centers cause, Spotlight PA reported Wednesday. Gov. Josh Shapiro has filed to intervene on the advocate's side.
Why it matters: PPL has forecast more data center demand than any other electric company in the state, according to Spotlight PA. Pennsylvania's electricity demand was nearly flat from 2001 to 2024 and is projected to rise more than 18% by 2030, almost entirely because of data centers. Who pays for the wires and power plants to serve them shows up on household bills.
What the complaint says
Consumer Advocate Darryl Lawrence filed the complaint in October (PUC docket C-2026-3065756). According to Spotlight PA's account of it:
- A $178 million line. For a planned transmission project in Luzerne County serving a potential data center campus, PPL would recover only 12% from the data center, leaving about $157 million for existing customers.
- Outage risk. It warns data center demand could cause "forced" outages for PPL customers, and asks that data centers' service be cut back first when the grid is overwhelmed.
- Low-income programs. Data centers' contributions to PPL's low-income assistance, now $11 million a year under an earlier settlement, should be tied to how much power they use rather than set as a fixed amount.
A PPL spokesperson told Spotlight PA the company is "committed to protecting customers, maintaining reliability" and to making sure large customers cover their project costs. PPL has proposed a new transmission rider that would assign some transmission costs directly to data centers.
The case is at an early stage, with testimony and hearings ahead. A final PUC decision isn't expected until July 2027.
The governor's role
Shapiro petitioned to intervene Oct. 15, his office said, calling it the first time in at least 15 years that a governor has intervened in a PUC proceeding. He wants a separate customer class for large data centers, with the costs of their demand assigned to that class, and safeguards for existing customers if supply can't keep up. "Pennsylvanians should not be left paying higher electric bills because of data center developers," he said.
On Wednesday, Shapiro also criticized a vote by members of PJM Interconnection, the regional grid operator that serves Pennsylvania, on new governance rules. In a statement, he called them "self-serving rules" that keep the grid "held captive by greedy corporate interests" and give "no meaningful voice" to elected leaders. He said the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission had "clearly identified major flaws in PJM's current governance" and that the rules make them worse. The statement didn't describe the rules or the vote count. Our earlier report covers PJM's December capacity auction.
What the legislature did
The House passed HB 1834, from Rep. Rob Matzie, 104-95 on March 24. House Democrats said it would bar utilities from passing the cost of data center development and related grid upgrades on to other customers. The Senate sent it to its Consumer Protection and Professional Licensure Committee on March 31, and its history shows no action since. With the Senate finished for the term, it dies Nov. 30.
Advertisement
Spotlight PA described it as the data center bill of House Energy Committee Chair Elizabeth Fiedler, a Philadelphia Democrat, that stalled in the Republican-controlled Senate. Our report on the data center pause bills covers other measures that stalled in the Senate.
The PUC's guidance
In May, the PUC issued non-binding guidance supporting a "but for" standard: data centers should pay for network upgrades that wouldn't be needed without them. In June, it approved a settlement in PPL's last rate case that added protections such as long-term contracts and exit fees for data centers, Spotlight PA reported.