On My Block · Pennsylvania Politics

EnergyData centers

The PUC wants data centers cut off before homes and hospitals in a grid emergency. Comments are due Dec. 11

A clarification order published Saturday narrows the Public Utility Commission's October proposal after federal regulators rejected PJM's plan for large loads. It keeps the core idea: data centers can't be classified as critical load.

The Public Utility Commission is asking for comments on rules that would require electric utilities to curtail data centers before homes, hospitals and schools when the grid runs short of power. A clarification order adopted Nov. 5 and published in Saturday's Pennsylvania Bulletin sets the deadlines: comments are due 20 days after publication and replies 30 days after, which by our count is Friday, Dec. 11, and Monday, Dec. 21.

Why it matters: data center growth is the biggest energy fight in Harrisburg and was a theme of this month's elections, Spotlight PA reported. The state's consumer advocate has also gone after data center costs (our report). The order describes PJM, the regional grid operator, finding a 6,831-megawatt capacity shortfall for the 2028-29 delivery year in its July auction. The question the PUC is asking is who loses power first if that shortfall ever leads to an emergency. "Essentially," the order says, "non-critical data centers should be curtailed before homes, hospitals, and schools."

Why the order was changed

On Oct. 1, the commission proposed tying utility curtailment plans to PJM's proposed "Interim Resource Adequacy Service." Under that plan, new data centers of 50 megawatts or more that didn't bring their own new power supply could be cut off first in a shortage.

On Oct. 9, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission rejected the core of PJM's plan, including the interim service and the requirement that new large loads find new capacity, according to the PUC's order. FERC accepted PJM's 50-megawatt large load definition and its large load registry, and encouraged states to keep working on their own policies.

So the PUC dropped the parts tied to PJM's plan and is moving ahead with the rest.

What the proposal would do

The order's appendix rewrites the PUC's emergency load control rules (52 Pa. Code Chapter 57). Among the provisions:

  • Who counts as a data center. A "computational load site" is one drawing at least 50 megawatts at a single site, or within a one-mile radius, that mainly runs software, artificial intelligence, cryptocurrency mining or other computing. Manufacturing facilities are excluded.
  • No critical-load exemption. Utilities couldn't classify any large load as critical load exempt from curtailment during emergencies.
  • An order of curtailment. In the worst emergencies, when utilities must cut firm customers, noncritical load goes first. Protected critical load is ranked:

- Level 1: hospitals, police, fire and EMS stations, and critical utility, energy, military and government infrastructure. Data centers are excluded. - Level 2: only the part of a data center with uninterruptible power that supports Level 1 facilities in real time, and only if its backup power fails or runs out. - Level 3: residential customers and businesses whose prolonged outage would create a risk to human safety or of uncontrolled environmental release.

  • Earlier steps. In less severe emergencies, utilities would curtail data center customers through interruptible rate schedules.
  • Notice and reports. Utilities would have to warn affected customers when practicable and file a report with the PUC within 24 hours of an event, listing how many customers lost power, for how long, and which kinds.

These are proposals. The commission would issue final rules after reviewing comments.

How to comment

Comments go to the PUC secretary at docket M-2026-3064961, through the commission's e-File system or by mail to the Commonwealth Keystone Building, 400 North St., Harrisburg. The order lists Clinton McKinley of the Bureau of Technical Utility Services (717-783-6161) for technical questions and Kriss E. Brown of the Law Bureau (717-787-4518) for legal ones.

Where the legislature is

Bills to pause or regulate data center development are stuck in the Senate and die when the session ends Nov. 30 (our report). The order cites Act 45 of 2025, which gives the PUC oversight of utility load forecasting, as one reason utilities would have to keep a registry of large loads and share it with the commission each year.

Support Pennsylvania Politics

Keep Pennsylvania Politics free for everyone

Pennsylvania Politics is free to read and built from public records. A monthly, yearly or one-time contribution from readers helps pay for the work.

Support our work

From $3 · Cancel anytime